Current:Home > reviewsAdults have a lot to say about book bans — but what about kids? -AssetLink
Adults have a lot to say about book bans — but what about kids?
TradeEdge Exchange View
Date:2025-04-10 01:11:11
There's a lot of discussion and debate about the rise in efforts to remove certain books from school libraries and curriculums. It usually involves adults debating the issue — but it's kids who are affected.
So how do young readers feel about book bans? We asked some.
We spoke with Sawyer, 12, from Arlington, Va., Theo, 9, from St. Louis, Mo., Priya, 14, and Ellie, 14, both from Austin, Texas. To protect their privacy, we're only using their first names.
Here's what they said:
Sawyer: I don't like it. It just feels weird that you're gonna, like, cut it off from them. ... Why are you trying to hide information from your kids? It just doesn't make a lot of sense. ... If you take something away from a kid, it kind of makes them want it more.
Theo: It's pretty much taking away books from people — like even books that people actually might like. If you ban every book, then there's not really going to be any books left to read. So what's the point of it?
Ellie: So many books are banned nowadays. I was looking up lists earlier and it's like hundreds of books... One of my favorite books that I recently found out was banned is Rick by Alex Gino. It's a book about a kid who learns that he's asexual, which is an LGBTQ orientation. ... I was just starting to question when I had read that book, and it really helped me sort of figure out that sort of thing. It was really interesting to me that a book that helped me so much and that I love so much would be like challenged or banned.
Priya: Books provide people with that exposure to different beliefs and different perspectives. And that's what breeds and fosters empathy and compassion for other people ... There was this book it was called The Mighty Heart of Sunny St. James. The girl's like 11 or 12. She gets a heart transplant. She's also dealing with the re-emergence of her mother into her life. And she's also exploring her sexuality as she's growing up, so it's kind of like a really sweet coming-of-age story. Then I was aware that some parents didn't want this to be a book that was offered to us. And I just didn't understand why it was harmful ... I really like the book because it was like a girl my age. And I just felt like I really connected with it.
Ellie: In like an elementary school, middle school library, having like an adult book with very adult themes should not be in the library. So in that case, it would be okay.
Priya: Obviously you don't want your 10-year-old reading a really sultry adult romance book because that's not age appropriate.
Sawyer: In [my] elementary school they were removed for gore and violence. I think that makes sense. You don't want to scare a kid. But if it's about information then you shouldn't ban it.
Priya: I would ask [the adults] why they think [a certain book] should be banned. And I would also ask them like ... what harm they see in this [book] ... Because I think ... it's important to understand all these different people's perspectives, just like books do. And I think we could probably come to a good conclusion.
Theo: I'd be pretty mad and a little upset [if a book was taken away], too. Yeah, I'd probably just buy a new one.
Priya: I go out of my way to read these banned books because I want to learn about how voices get silenced in our society ... and why.
This piece was edited for radio and digital by Meghan Sullivan.
veryGood! (728)
Related
- 'Most Whopper
- Tornadoes hit parts of Texas, more severe weather in weekend forecast
- The Kentucky Derby could be a wet one. Early favorites Fierceness, Sierra Leone have won in the slop
- Mississippi city council member pleads guilty to federal drug charges
- All That You Wanted to Know About She’s All That
- An AI-powered fighter jet took the Air Force’s leader for a historic ride. What that means for war
- Former Boy Scout volunteer sentenced to 22 years in prison for hiding cameras in camp bathrooms
- Judge denies pretrial release of a man charged with killing a Chicago police officer
- 'Malcolm in the Middle’ to return with new episodes featuring Frankie Muniz
- Police defend decision not to disclose accidental gunshot during Columbia protest response
Ranking
- Hackers hit Rhode Island benefits system in major cyberattack. Personal data could be released soon
- Tiffany Haddish Reveals the Surprising Way She's Confronting Online Trolls
- Lewis Hamilton faces awkward questions about Ferrari before Miami F1 race with Mercedes-AMG
- Captain sentenced to four years following deadly fire aboard dive boat Conception in California
- Stamford Road collision sends motorcyclist flying; driver arrested
- Walgreens limits online sales of Gummy Mango candy to 1 bag a customer after it goes viral
- Instagram teams up with Dua Lipa, launches new IG Stories stickers
- Person fatally shot by police after allegedly pointing weapon at others ID’d as 35-year-old man
Recommendation
Buckingham Palace staff under investigation for 'bar brawl'
Gambling bill to allow lottery and slots remains stalled in the Alabama Senate
Three groups are suing New Jersey to block an offshore wind farm
A judge is forcing Hawaii to give wildfire investigation documents to lawyers handling lawsuits
Civic engagement nonprofits say democracy needs support in between big elections. Do funders agree?
Lewis Hamilton faces awkward questions about Ferrari before Miami F1 race with Mercedes-AMG
Safety lapses contributed to patient assaults at Oregon State Hospital, federal report says
What's a whistleblower? Key questions about employee protections after Boeing supplier dies